Seismological Research Letters; January/February 2009; v. 80; no. 1;
p. 136-148; DOI: 10.1785/gssrl.80.1.136
© 2009 Seismological Society of America
Energy Magnitude: A Case Study for Southern Ontario/Western Quebec (Canada)
The conventional methods for rapid determination of earthquake magnitude
are based mainly on peak-to-peak amplitudes of specific phases on a seismic
trace. Today, broadband digital records are readily accessible in real time,
enabling the use of more information from a seismogram for rapid magnitude
calculation.
The aim of this work is to introduce a new magnitude scale for routine
seismological analysis, denoted ME (P-wave,
S-wave+coda, or both). This magnitude scale uses the signal energy
and is illustrated here with a case study from southern Ontario/western Quebec
(Canada). Traditional types of magnitude scales, based on the estimated
maximum velocity (mb) and Richter local magnitude
(ML), as well as the moment magnitude
(MW), and some other magnitude types, based on the coda
energy (MCoda) and envelope area
(MEnv) are also computed for the study area for
comparative purposes. The proposed approach employed for this study can be
easily applied to any other region of the world.
The developed automatic procedure allowed the simultaneous computation of
different magnitudes and different trace components and types of waves. The
data used for this research are from 238 well-recorded earthquakes between
1991 and 2006 in southern Ontario/western Quebec/northern Ohio/northern NY
State (1.0 < mN < 5.5).
The results of our work show that, in general, magnitude values based on
signal energy ME give less scattered estimates than
magnitude values based on peak-to-peak measurements. We recommend using
ME (S + coda) scale (vertical component) for
quantifying the earthquakes in the study area in the future. The magnitude
formula for this scale is given by ME = 0.5log
S + 0.92logD +
3.56 + S, where
S is the signal energy
defined here (Zv2s
t,
vS is measured in mm/s,
t is the sample
interval in seconds), D is the epicentral distance in km, and
S is the station correction. The new ME magnitude
can be used for a quick estimate of the MW magnitude for
the study region using the relationship: MW =
ME – 0.51 (for earthquakes with
ME
2.6), obtained here.
Copyright © 2009 by Seismological Society of America